Logo with the text 'Pie Guy's Pies' featuring a slice of pie and various fruits.

Must-Try Pies

Indulge in the delightful flavors of Pie Guy’s Pies, your local Flagstaff favorite, sold right here at Silver Saddle Center! Trained by Marie Callender’s and baking pies since 1991, Pie Guy’s Pies has a local commercial kitchen creating handcrafted pies in a variety of seasonal flavors that will satisfy any sweet tooth. Hurry in and grab a pie—before they sell out!

Taste the magic of Flagstaff’s Pie Guy’s Pies with every delectable bite. Enjoy your pie on our outdoor patio and eating area! Check daily for the current flavor roundup and availability.

A bisbeeberry pie in a cardboard box from Pie Guy's Pies in Flagstaff, AZ with a visible label.
A pie topped with whipped cream and sliced almonds on a dark surface.
A lemon meringue pie with browned meringue topping on a wooden surface.

~Anne W., via Yelp Reviews

“…The big plus is "Pie Guy" pies made right in Flagstaff. This morning, the pies were still warm and are gone by the end of the day. Thank you for buying local, especially when the prices aren’t all that much higher and you are helping support a fine staff.”